Why Abbey Sharp’s Nutrition Advice is Misleading & Dangerous. What She’s Not Telling You.

Abbey Sharp is one of the most well-known Dietitians on social media, particularly on YouTube but is her advice really science-based? While she presents herself as a balanced and evidence-based Nutritionist, much of her content misrepresents how the body processes macronutrients, pushes restrictive calorie-counting, and promotes corporate food industry interests.

This article will break down why her claims are misleading and dangerous, what she gets wrong about metabolism and fat storage, and why her food sponsorships create a conflict of interest.

1. Does Abbey Sharp Understand Carbohydrates?

Abbey Sharp often warns about eating too many carbs, claiming they contribute to weight gain. She implies that moderating carbohydrate intake is necessary for weight management, despite research showing the opposite.

What She Claims:

• "If you eat too many carbs, they will be stored as fat."
• "Carbs spike insulin, which causes fat storage."
• "A high-fat, low-carb diet is better for satiety."

The Truth About Carbs & Fat Storage:

✔ Humans are naturally designed to eat a high-carb diet. Cultures like the Okinawans, Kitavans, and Tarahumara Indians have thrived on 80-90% carbohydrate-based diets while remaining lean and largely disease-free.

✔ Carbohydrates do not turn into fat easily. De novo lipogenesis (DNL), the process of converting carbs to fat, is highly inefficient in humans. Carbs are burned for energy, stored as glycogen, or wasted as heat. Only rarely stored as fat in laboratory experiments with extreme overfeeding that cannot be reproduced daily in the real world.

✔ A high-carb diet supports metabolism. Cutting carbs slows down thyroid function (T3), increases cortisol, and reduces leptin, leading to fat storage and slowed metabolism.

📌 Bottom Line: Abbey Sharp’s misrepresentation of carbohydrates ignores historical evidence, metabolic science, and real-world examples of high-carb diets supporting longevity and leanness.

2. The Myth of "Everything in Moderation"

One of Abbey Sharp’s biggest claims is that all foods fit in a healthy diet, even ultra-processed, high-fat, and protein-heavy foods. But does “everything in moderation” really work?

What She Claims:

• "You can eat anything as long as it’s in moderation!"
• "No food is bad, it’s all about balance."
• "Processed foods are fine as long as they fit into your daily calories."

Why This Approach Fails:

✔ Highly processed fatty foods override natural hunger cues. Studies show that hyper-palatable foods (junk food) disrupt the body's natural satiety signals, leading to overconsumption and cravings.

✔ Food quality matters more than calorie counting. Whole foods like fruits regulate appetite naturally, while processed fatty foods lead to passive overeating.

✔ The food industry benefits from the “moderation” myth. Ultra-processed food companies push this idea because it allows them to market unhealthy products as acceptable in small amounts.

📌 Bottom Line: Abbey Sharp’s “everything in moderation” stance ignores how processed foods are designed to override satiety, keep people overeating and obese.

3. Misleading Claims About Metabolism & Fat Storage

Abbey Sharp often oversimplifies metabolism, suggesting that weight loss is just about calories in vs. calories out, without addressing how different macronutrients affect metabolism and fat storage.

What She Claims:

• "Fat doesn’t make you fat."
• "As long as you stay within your calorie limits, you won’t gain weight."
• "Calories in, calories out is the most important factor in weight loss."

The Truth About Fat Storage & Metabolism:

✔ Fat is stored far more efficiently than carbohydrates. Unlike carbs, which must go through an inefficient process (DNL) to be converted into fat, dietary fat is directly stored with 98% efficiency.

✔ Macronutrients are not equal. A high-fat meal vs. a high-carb meal has very different effects on metabolism, satiety, and fat storage.

✔ Metabolism is hormone-driven, not just calorie-based. Insulin, leptin, ghrelin, cortisol, and thyroid hormones all impact weight regulation, meaning calorie restriction alone is an incomplete approach.

📌 Bottom Line: Abbey Sharp’s focus on calorie counting ignores how metabolism is regulated by hormones and the source of the calories, not just energy intake.

4. Abbey Sharp’s Unethical Food Sponsorships

Perhaps the biggest red flag is Abbey Sharp’s paid partnerships with processed food companies, which create a conflict of interest in her nutrition advice.

Who Has She Taken Sponsorships From?

• Processed food companies
• Dairy industry
• Fast food chains
• Junk food brands

Why This is Unethical:

✔ Corporate sponsorships influence nutrition advice. If a dietitian gets paid to promote processed foods, dairy, or high-fat junk foods, they are not a neutral or reliable source of information.

✔ She downplays the risks of unhealthy foods. By taking money from food companies, she has a financial incentive to dismiss concerns about processed foods, dairy, and high-fat diets.

✔ She is marketing, not educating. Sponsorship deals blur the line between science-based nutrition and corporate advertising.

📌 Bottom Line: Abbey Sharp is not an unbiased dietitian, her content is shaped by the food industry, making her recommendations unreliable.

Below is a statement from Abbey’s website:

5. Abbey Sharp’s Misrepresentation of Sugar and Fruit

Abbey Sharp spreads misinformation about sugar, often making people fear both refined sugar and natural sugars from fruit. She pushes the idea that sugar is harmful while failing to acknowledge that the body processes all sugars the same way, whether from fruit, table sugar, or other sources.

What She Claims:

• "Eating too much sugar, even from fruit, leads to weight gain and metabolic issues."
• "Refined sugar is bad for you”
• "Fructose contributes to insulin resistance and fatty liver disease."

Why This Approach Fails:

✔ Sugar is sugar. The body does not differentiate between fructose from fruit, sucrose from table sugar, or glucose from starches. All sugars are broken down into simple molecules and used for energy.

✔ Carbohydrates, including sugar, fuel metabolism. A high-carb diet, whether from fruits, refined sugar, or starches, supports thyroid function, energy levels, and overall metabolic health. The real issue isn’t sugar but excess fat intake, which impairs sugar metabolism.

✔ There is no evidence that sugar causes obesity or disease when dietary fat is low. Studies linking sugar to weight gain or insulin resistance fail to account for the role of excess fat in blocking glucose uptake and leading to metabolic dysfunction.

✔ Her advice can lead to disordered eating and unnecessary sugar restriction. By demonizing sugar, Abbey Sharp encourages fear around a vital energy source, which can push people toward unhealthy low-carb diets, energy crashes, and an unhealthy relationship with food.

📌 Bottom Line: Abbey Sharp’s anti-sugar stance is not just misleading, it’s dangerous. Demonizing sugar creates unnecessary fear and can push people toward restrictive, low-energy diets that harm metabolism and long-term health.

Final Thoughts: Why Abbey Sharp’s Advice is Incorrect, Outdated, and Dangerous

If you’ve been following Abbey Sharp, you might think that calorie counting is the key to weight loss, carbs should be moderated, and “everything in moderation” works. But in reality, her advice is based on outdated diet culture myths and influenced by food industry sponsorships.

Here’s What the Science Really Says:

 ✔ Calorie restriction slows metabolism, fueling your body is the key to long-term success.
✔ Carbs don’t make you fat, excess fat intake does.
✔ Whole, fruit, and plant-based foods with added sugar regulate appetite naturally, while processed high fat foods promote overconsumption.
✔ Nutrition advice should be based on unbiased science, not corporate sponsorships.

📌 Final Takeaway: Abbey Sharp’s nutrition advice promotes restrictive dieting, ignores the metabolic advantages of high-carb, low-fat eating, and serves corporate interests more than genuine health education. Avoid dietitians who are “paid for” by food corporations.

Take the Next Step: Join My VIP Membership & 12-Month Fruit-Based Course

If you’re ready to break free from restrictive dieting, calorie counting, and misinformation, I invite you to:

📖 Read My Books – Gain the knowledge and confidence to transform your health and embrace a fruit-fueled lifestyle. Click here. 

 🎓 Join My 12-Month Course – A step-by-step program designed to help you succeed with long-term, sustainable results. Click here. 

Take control of your health and start transforming today.

Yours fruitfully,

Freelee.